65 Comments
User's avatar
Grace's avatar

What's truly sad is that there are many trans women who don't adhere to these language contortions. They acknowledge their unique status. Saying trans women are trans women is fine with them. Why can't their voices be heard? But no, they get cancelled, too.

Trish Hamlin's avatar

You’re exactly right. I’m a trans woman who doesn’t buy into any of the woke nonsense about actually being born female. I keep my status private and feel lucky to just be able to blend in. No one in my day to day life knows my history.

I would never, however, challenge biological women in competitive sports. How selfish it is for any mediocre male athlete to stand in the way of opportunities for women to excel.

Having said that, gender dysphoria, whatever it is, is no joke. I wouldn’t wish it upon anyone.

Richard's avatar

I appreciate your insights. Please don’t let the argumentative person(s) get you down.

Grace's avatar

I appreciate the note.

Pawsative's avatar

It’s the battle of the Autogynephile vs the homosexual transexual. That is why the two different types of trans need to be public ally discussed.

Danaura Mathew's avatar

That is because Shier has to pander to people who want to praise her. She never talk about why sexual inverts exist. If she really cared about sexual inverted transsexuals, she wouldn't lie. But, she does.

Genevieve Gluck's avatar

The elephant in the room is pornography. The idea that women can be reduced to an appearance, a hyper-feminine performance, sexual submissiveness, and body parts comes directly from a porn-saturated culture, and all of these men are getting their ideas about women from porn consumption or the society it has shaped.

Whereas women and girls are seeking to escape objectification, such men see women as only objectification, an experience they can possess, not as humans in full ownership of our own female bodies.

Alicia Ochs's avatar

Absolutely believe this and needs to be studied. Porn now is so graphic and easily accessible and such an issue for men to get addicted to.

Danaura Mathew's avatar

"Body parts"? Are you saying that saying only women have vaginas is because of porn consumption.

Pawsative's avatar

Pornography seems to be the primary vehicle that causes Autogynephilia. During masturbation teenage boys come across he-she ladyboy porn and it causes an erotic target locator error.

Magz's avatar

Well said Abigail. What I cannot comprehend are the adults who are complicit in this lie. Thank you for standing up for women and girls.

Pawsative's avatar

They want to be ‘nice’ or they just want to be subversive and transgressive and intentionally upset people and destroy society.

Pawsative's avatar

Also mass hysteria, misinformation and disinformation by subversive and transgressive individuals.

Ann's avatar

Great article. This sort of polite lie dominates women's circles because that's what we're raised on - don't upset men, don't make them uncomfortable for even a second. You see it in the lack of the same fervor toward transgender identifying females.

Cancel culture is the one sphere of control women dominate. We police each other into submission. It's a shame, but hopefully the tide is turning.

Pawsative's avatar

It seems to be based on the home (women and children) group and the away (men) group. Males who can’t make it in to the away group stay within the home group as non-men. Women and non-men won’t allow men into their spaces so once they make it in to institutions they colonize them and force the men out who by the way do not feel it is fair for them to compete with women and non-men.

Majority Quotas for Men need to be mandated in all institutions to counteract the tyrannical exclusionary behavior of women and non-men for a truly diverse and inclusive society. Women and non-women should be excluded from physically competitive fields such as warfighting where men’s natural instinct to not compete with women and non-women is dangerous.

Venus's avatar

Thank you for creating this space and your continued advocacy on behalf of women and girls. ♥️

Grace's avatar

Thank you for everything you do! Looking forward to hearing more truth. Hopefully this censorship will wake people up to the continuous attacks on the free market of ideas.

Dru's avatar

They're taking women's right to negotiate and navigate spaces with males. Many of us were fine with accommodating trans-identified males under circumstances where we felt safe in doing so. But you give an inch and men take ten thousand miles.

The activist lobby is actually trying to remove sex as a characteristic in human rights legislation, statistical reporting, medical research, and every other area they can with no input from the public. See Benjamin Boyce's interview with Katherine Deves. It's shocking.

Danaura Mathew's avatar

LOL. Transsexuals don't identify as trans.

Boss Hogg's avatar

LOL. Do please explain the difference for us less-informed folk.

Pawsative's avatar

Autogynephiles effectively erase homosexual transexuals. It is part of their pathology - narcissism and self denial of having Autogynephilia.

jane wright's avatar

Thanks for establishing The Truth Fairy - much needed.

Pawsative's avatar

Reminds me of the gay term for heterosexuals - breeders.

Pawsative's avatar

There is a big difference between the two types of transgenders - autogynephiles (who are very vocal men with an overwhelming paraphilia and who dominate the transgender discourse) and homosexual transexuals (who generally keep their lives private and can pretty much pass 90-99% in public).

Trish Hamlin's avatar

You are right Pawsitive. Clinical studies done years ago, but now essentially “canceled”, proved the existence of the two broad categories. Non homosexual “gender dysphoria” almost always aligns iwith sexual stimulation caused by the thought of being female (autogynephilia).

However, if there’s one topic that is verboten in the trans community it is precisely that - autogynephilia. The shame associated with it is just too strong.

So rather than deal with the truth, they delude themselves and indoctrinate others with the dogma of having actually been born women.

Of course, while society at large is burdened by this nonsense, the dogma and shame also prevent honest discussion about the problem and, ultimately, stop people from pursuing treatments less drastic than surgery (such as chemical castration).

Please be kind, autogynephilia is no joke. Unbeknownst to any mother, their four year old son may be afflicted with it and, in shame, completely internalize it, becoming an easy target for some virtue signaling trans zealot who will convince the child that surgery is the only solution. Once that thought is placed in the child’s mind it may not be possible to get it out.

We need to find a way to speak openly about such things if we are to protect our sons and, for that matter, the rest of us.

Pawsative's avatar

Autogynephilia doesn’t begin until around 16 years old. Homosexual transexuals start around 3 years old and it is persistent and consistent unlike Autogynephiles who will feast and purge until they can no longer control the female persons that they created and are overwhelmed by it. That is one reason why they are so incensed over ‘dead-naming’. The female persons ‘killed’ their hated natal male host after a decades long struggle.

Trish Hamlin's avatar

Hi Pawsative ... thank you for your reply.

Personal histories can vary. In my case, the sexual arousal began at or before age four and was persistent throughout my life until I finally transitioned and it, thankfully, went away. I wish there had been a different cure available.

I believe GD is more apparent at a young age with overtly feminine boys. For others, the shame keeps it hidden and it only really manifests itself later in life -as you noted. You’re also right in your assessment about autogynephiles eventually becoming overwhelmed.

I used to run a transgender community center in a major city. I was run out of town on a rail by the vocal autogynephiles you mention when I wouldn’t promote the “I’m really a woman nonsense”. I have first hand experience with lots of cases.

In my case, I live a quiet life with my two adopted daughters and no one is the wiser about my pre-transition history. I’m lucky; I pass well and have even modeled.

Other than writing anonymously about my personal experiences I make no waves. It’s informative for others and therapeutic for me. I try to be absolutely honest. Anything less would be wrong.

I wish you well.

Pawsative's avatar

Part of the pathology of Autogynephilia is to have childhood memories that are not verifiable and pseudo-homosexuality.

It’s true that some Autogynephiles can look attractive but being able to pass as biological women or as homosexual transexuals isn’t possible. Autogynephiles have gone through puberty and have had years of testosterone masculinizing their bodies. Even with surgery and hormone treatments they won’t be able to pass as biological women or homosexual transexuals, but again, some can look attractive without a doubt.

MYD's avatar

Can you give more information about the clinical studies you reference?

Richard M Roberts's avatar

I'm waiting for Mike Tyson to self identify as a lightweight, and take the lightweight title.

Trish Hamlin's avatar

Hi Richard,

Just something to ponder ...

Anyone could have a child who struggles with these issues. Now, I’m definitely in the category of someone who would discourage transitioning. Encouraging hormone blockers and such is nothing less than evil.

However, making light of the condition makes it harder for children to talk about it. They internalize their shame and are more likely to be victimized by trans zealots who encourage surgery and hormones as a solution.

I wish you well. Please don’t let the vocal woke warriors hate all of us.

I wouldn’t wish gender dysphoria on anyone.

Pawsative's avatar

If a child has all the signs at a very young age that they are a sexual invert - homosexual transexual - parents should definitely look into putting the boys on birth control pills around age 12 to prevent the masculinizing effects of puberty. Girls, on the other hand, should not be put on any testosterone or other hormones or puberty blockers or have surgery. The affect of male hormones on girls is irreversible. Surgery will cause sterility. Most girls will grow out of their gender dysphoria and many boys will too. Therefore, a girl should not make any decision about surgery or taking male hormones until she is an adult.

The key is early onset around 3 years old and persistent and consistent behavior from the child that they are the other sex, have crushes on the same sex, and want to play and socialize with the opposite sex and are attracted to opposite sex interests and activities.

Putting a boy on birth control pills will delay puberty but once they are taken off the pills they will quickly masculinize. They will not be irreversibly harmed by taking birth control pills. Few homosexual transexuals get bottom surgery though they will often get top surgery - breast implants.

That said transgenderism is very rare. There has been a transgendered mass hysteria among young women fueled by social media for the last few years and now many videos can be found of young women who now regret transitioning.

Mass hysteria is a real phenomenon. Fear of COVID became the latest mass hysteria. The public can be worked up in to mass hysteria by the media and subversives. The Salem witch trials along with prior witch trials were mass hysteria. Fears of ‘white supremacists’ is another example of leaders trying to whip up mass hysteria. Don’t fall for the latest mass hysteria.

Beeswax's avatar

There's nothing wrong with investigating HRT for a gender-nonconforming young son. But please, leave him alone until he goes into puberty and let him tell you whether he's an effeminate gay man or a transwoman. Fifty years of studies have demonstrated that puberty is the bright line: the majority of these boys settle with their sex and come out as gay, but there's a critical minority who find that their gender dysphoria doesn't fade. (As you point out, transgenderism is very rare.) Don't shame your son or push him in any particular direction. Offer insight therapy (neither gender-critical or gender-affirming) to help him figure it out, in case he's struggling with internalized homophobia or other issues that he hasn't discussed with you. Let him know that whether he turns out to be gay or trans (or who knows? even straight!), it's fine with you. That way he'll remain true to himself and won't feel pressured to conform to your or society's expectations.

Also, I have heard from detransitioned males that HRT is not always reversible in boys. I've heard of boys getting stuck with a micro penis or one that never grows to its full size. Sexual function and libido may be negatively affected, and overall growth may be stunted. Parents should have access to a good endocrinologist to help a boy normalize as male if he determines that he's not trans after all.

Danaura Mathew's avatar

Internalized homophobia is a term to gaslight young sexual inverts to call their own biology as "homophobia". Stop that non-sense.

Pawsative's avatar

Homosexuals aren’t ‘gay’. ‘Gay’ is a lifestyle that is primarily made up of pederasts, pedophiles, sexual paraphilias - narcissism, sadomasochism, and political, social, hierarchical, economic or situational motives.

Homosexual is a sexual orientation, it is innate as is heterosexuality.

Pederasty and pedophila are cyclical - the abused will grow up to be the abuser. It should never be accepted or normalized - ever.

Pawsative's avatar

My understanding is that homosexual transexuals will acknowledge what they are - biological males, but autogynephiles are the ones who insist that “transwomen are women.” Yet HSTS are far more convincingly female.

Beeswax's avatar

I think that's almost always true. But there is the occasional autogynephile who acknowledges that that's what he, is but still feels better presenting as female; for instance, Debbie Hayton.

https://quillette.com/2020/02/02/i-may-have-gender-dysphoria-but-i-still-prefer-to-base-my-life-on-biology-not-fantasy/

Hayton says: "I speak from experience when I say that it’s difficult for autogynephiles to admit the simple truth that they are simply heterosexual males who use the conceit of female self-identification as a means to rationalize their sexual attraction to a female version of themselves. As any sex therapist can attest, people often feel ashamed about unusual sexual proclivities. Shame is a powerful emotion, and a person who suffers from it often will be driven to control their narrative in a way that protects their sense of self-worth.

"Autogynephilia drove my own transsexualism. And I can attest that there is huge mental dissonance built up in the brain of a male who somehow is heterosexually attracted to their own body. This paradox can have a devastating effect on one’s mental health. I also can attest that the process of gender reassignment can help alleviate that dissonance. My critique of gender ideology should in no way be interpreted as an argument to deny such therapies to males such as myself."

Pawsative's avatar

Yes I’ve heard Autogynephiles admit that they their sexual paraphilia fills them with great shame. I’m sure it is extremely difficult to live with, on the other hand, they tend to be highly narcissistic and narcissists are pretty awful and abusive in endless ways.

Danaura Mathew's avatar

Hayton is a liar. She said she had gender confusion at 4. Like 4? An AGP?

Blythe Lynn's avatar

Thank you for using your strong and clear voice to advocate for women and girls. Thank you for articulating the issues with your insight and depth. Your voice will change minds.

Alicia Ochs's avatar

Thank you for everything you are doing. We need to stay grounded in reality. It feels like women need to start from ground zero for our rights all over again. This is crazy.