255 Comments
Jan 1Liked by Abigail Shrier

First article I read in the New Year(it hit my inbox right about midnight and I read it a few minutes past). Unsurprisingly, considering the author, that it may end up being the best, and most important, piece I'll read this year, a scant few minutes into it.

Expand full comment

The Jewish Pioneers of Sexual Degeneracy in 1920s Berlin . . . by Michael Walsh . . .

IN 1919, Magnus Hirschfeld and Arthur Kronfeld, founded the “Institut für Sexualwissenschaft” (Institute for ‘Sexual Research’) in Berlin. Both were active in the German Communist Party and were prominent members of Berlin’s Jewish community.

A multitude of degenerate services were offered at the institute, including the first surgical sex changes in modern history, abortions, lectures and ‘sex counseling’, room rentals, a large library of pornography and erotic literature on every possible perversion (including bestiality and pedophilia), and a Museum of Sex featuring a wide array of homosexual fetish items, dildos, “masturbation machines”, etc.

The institute hosted tens of thousands of visitors each year, including school class field trips. Hirschfeld was a notorious sodomite, popularly known in the Berlin gay scene by his cross-dresser name Tante Magnesia.

He also founded a committee for gay rights and wrote and published many degenerate books and journals, including Jahrbuch für Sexuelle Zwischenstufen (Yearbook for Intermediate Sexual Types). In fact, he’s the sinister figure that coined the term ‘transvestite’. Hirschfeld campaigned to end the Berlin police department’s arrest of cross-dressers and prostitutes . . .

https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/06/the-jewish-pioneers-of-sexual-degeneracy-in-1920s-berlin/

Expand full comment

Thank you Abigail!

Here is something to do: get this protect-kids law on the ballot in California!

https://protectkidsca.com

If we can get it on the ballot, it is very likely to pass.

Remember: in 2020, the exact same California electorate that voted for Biden 2-to-1 over Trump ALSO voted to reject race-based "affirmative action", 55% to 45%.

A popular defeat for gender ideology in California will send shock waves across the country and around the world.

If you can, please help!

Expand full comment

None of this will work.

Any legislation will be vetoed by the governor (even Republicans like DeWine veto these), challenged in courts, appealed, etc. It will fail.

California voted for Prop. 187 to deny social services to illegals nearly 30 years ago, and it passed. How did that work out?

California voted against gay marriage several years ago, and they supported a ban. How did that work out in the long run?

The only way this will end is if the medical industry begins to lose money on it instead of make money on it. Anything else will be overturned, denied, vetoed, etc. because the people who run this system will not allow it. Just like they've decided, now, to allow criticism of DEI, black academics, "wokeness" (which they caused), etc.

Expand full comment

Hi Kat, you are correct in the area of legislation however, this ballot initiative is different. It is the one way that Californians have an opportunity to create law without the necessity of a governor approving it; therefore, the governor and the legislature have nothing to do with the petition that is currently being offered on the ballot for 2024. It will take all of us to collect the million signatures necessary to put this initiative on the ballot and I urge you and any of your friends and colleagues that think the way you do to please help us get this on the ballot so that the governor can not VETO!! Studies have shown that roughly 65 percent favor this initiative among Democrats. I took the training on how to properly gather the signatures to put this on the ballots directly to the voters bypassing the governor and the legislature!! You can too. Please go to Protect Kids California Act to learn more! Thank you.

Expand full comment

Can somebody still file a lawsuit against it to get it overturned?

Expand full comment

Yes they could and likely will if it passes. I haven’t studied the language in detail but I expect it has been drafted to be as bulletproof as possible. It’s only about kids medically transitioning and carves out those already on a medical regimen.

Expand full comment

The Jewish Pioneers of Sexual Degeneracy in 1920s Berlin . . . by Michael Walsh . . .

IN 1919, Magnus Hirschfeld and Arthur Kronfeld, founded the “Institut für Sexualwissenschaft” (Institute for ‘Sexual Research’) in Berlin. Both were active in the German Communist Party and were prominent members of Berlin’s Jewish community.

A multitude of degenerate services were offered at the institute, including the first surgical sex changes in modern history, abortions, lectures and ‘sex counseling’, room rentals, a large library of pornography and erotic literature on every possible perversion (including bestiality and pedophilia), and a Museum of Sex featuring a wide array of homosexual fetish items, dildos, “masturbation machines”, etc.

The institute hosted tens of thousands of visitors each year, including school class field trips. Hirschfeld was a notorious sodomite, popularly known in the Berlin gay scene by his cross-dresser name Tante Magnesia.

He also founded a committee for gay rights and wrote and published many degenerate books and journals, including Jahrbuch für Sexuelle Zwischenstufen (Yearbook for Intermediate Sexual Types). In fact, he’s the sinister figure that coined the term ‘transvestite’. Hirschfeld campaigned to end the Berlin police department’s arrest of cross-dressers and prostitutes . . .

https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/06/the-jewish-pioneers-of-sexual-degeneracy-in-1920s-berlin/

Expand full comment

Sure, anybody can file a lawsuit about anything. But in this case, any such lawsuit will ultimately end up with SCOTUS, where we have an excellent chance of prevailing.

Also, getting this on the ballot, and then getting a popular vote in favor of it, will send a huge message, including to malpractice insuarance providers (who are already starting to understand the risk). The more awareness there is, the more likely it is that malpractice lawsuits will be filed.

This is a war, and it must be fought on all possible fronts, even on fronts where the chances of success may seem small.

Though in this case, I think the chances are actually very good.

Expand full comment

Organizations like Black Lives Matter, the Catholic Church, Anti-Defamation League, Southern Poverty Law Center, NAMBLA, corporations like Disney, other 501(c)(3) Tax-exempt Corporations, and teacher unions should be completely shut down with the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO).

Under the law, the meaning of racketeering activity is set out at 18 U.S.C. § 1961: Any violation of state statutes against gambling, murder, kidnapping, extortion, arson, robbery, bribery, dealing in obscene matter, or dealing in a controlled substance or listed chemical (as defined in the Controlled Substances Act); . . .

Individuals or organizations can use the RICO Act to file civil claims against racketeering activities performed as an ongoing criminal enterprise.

If your business or property suffers at the hands of a criminal organization, such as a corporation or bank, you may have a RICO claim.

The federal civil RICO statute (18 U.S. Code § 1964) says a plaintiff who brings a successful civil RICO action “shall recover threefold the damages he sustains and the cost of the suit, including a reasonable attorney’s fee.”

Under the Florida Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organization (RICO) Act, a plaintiff can file a civil lawsuit against defendant(s) who engaged in a pattern of racketeering activity. Notably, a plaintiff that files a successful civil RICO claim can seek treble damages.

https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/we-cant-afford-healthcare-for-american

Expand full comment

To fix government or anything that is part of government we must first:

1. Correctly identify our biggest problem as the corruption in our governing systems.

2. Find common ground and unify against this problem

How?

With these three simple steps:

https://joshketry.substack.com/p/how-to-fix-corrupt-government-in

Expand full comment

The Jewish Pioneers of Sexual Degeneracy in 1920s Berlin . . . by Michael Walsh . . .

IN 1919, Magnus Hirschfeld and Arthur Kronfeld, founded the “Institut für Sexualwissenschaft” (Institute for ‘Sexual Research’) in Berlin. Both were active in the German Communist Party and were prominent members of Berlin’s Jewish community.

A multitude of degenerate services were offered at the institute, including the first surgical sex changes in modern history, abortions, lectures and ‘sex counseling’, room rentals, a large library of pornography and erotic literature on every possible perversion (including bestiality and pedophilia), and a Museum of Sex featuring a wide array of homosexual fetish items, dildos, “masturbation machines”, etc.

The institute hosted tens of thousands of visitors each year, including school class field trips. Hirschfeld was a notorious sodomite, popularly known in the Berlin gay scene by his cross-dresser name Tante Magnesia.

He also founded a committee for gay rights and wrote and published many degenerate books and journals, including Jahrbuch für Sexuelle Zwischenstufen (Yearbook for Intermediate Sexual Types). In fact, he’s the sinister figure that coined the term ‘transvestite’. Hirschfeld campaigned to end the Berlin police department’s arrest of cross-dressers and prostitutes . . .

https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/06/the-jewish-pioneers-of-sexual-degeneracy-in-1920s-berlin/

Expand full comment

I don't live in CA and know very little about law and politics but I am wondering if it can be somehow piggybacked on proposition 65 that requires those carcinogen warnings on so many things (even non- food items). So if the testosterone and estrogen vials came with a huge warning about potential carcinogens, maybe it will give the Whole - Food- shopping wealthy young people and their parents at least a tiny pause?

Expand full comment

Nice idea but our prescriptions already come with a huge pamphlet of warnings which nobody reads. Like Prop 65 warnings which are universally ignored.

Expand full comment

How about running a series of public service announcements about the many dangers of "transgender" medicine. Make them like the anti-cigarette announcements. Transdanger medicine.

Expand full comment

[26] The fairies are not to be seized on, and brought to answer for the hurt they do. So also the ecclesiastics vanish away from the tribunals of civil justice.

[27] The ecclesiastics take from young men the use of reason, by certain charms compounded of metaphysics, and miracles, and traditions, and abused Scripture, whereby they are good for nothing else but to execute what they command them. The fairies likewise are said to take young children out of their cradles, and to change them into natural fools, which common people do therefore call elves, and are apt to mischief.

[28] In what shop or operatory the fairies make their enchantment, the old wives have not determined. But the operatories of the clergy are well enough known to be the universities, that received their discipline from authority pontifical.

[29] When the fairies are displeased with anybody, they are said to send their elves to pinch them. The ecclesiastics, when they are displeased with any civil state, make also their elves, that is, superstitious, enchanted subjects, to pinch their princes, by preaching sedition; or one prince, enchanted with promises, to pinch another.

[30] The fairies marry not; but there be amongst them incubi that have copulation with flesh and blood. The priests also marry not.

-

Hobbes, Thomas. Leviathan: with selected variants from the Latin edition of 1668. Ed. Edwin Curley. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1994 . . . Leviathan: Part IV. Of the Kingdom of Darkness . . . Chap. xlvii. Of the Benefit that proceedeth from such Darkness, and to Whom it Accrueth . . . https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/leviathan-part-iv-of-the-kingdom

Expand full comment

There is a lot said about virtue signalling and victimhood among the social justice leftish, but as a former member of that milieu (and now fiercely post-tribal) I see just as much of it on the right. And there's comfort in feeling you were right, long before the converts. But that is just ego and sometimes winning an argument demands the courage of showing a certain humility by not crowing. Abigail calls it exactly right here 💪

Expand full comment

Fuck that. An eye for an eye. I'm tired of being bent over.

Expand full comment

Haha. “I told you so” is so damn tempting. But at the end of the day don’t we want to change their minds? If they get to “yeah I guess you’re right” then we owe them the grace to say “cool, welcome home”

Expand full comment

YES!!

Expand full comment

Excellent and highly truthful points were made, as usual. But please, please remember that boys and young men are also being irreparably harmed by gender ideology as well. Of the ROGD group your wonderful book discussed about 30% are male. Please don't leave them out of the discussion. Those of us who love boys ruining their lives and bodies with this trans nonsense don't want to be left out of the conversation. Our culture is horrible to boys. Especially white boys. They need support too. And they need to be protected from the destructive cult of transgenderism.

Expand full comment
Jan 1Liked by Abigail Shrier

Amen. As a mom to boy ruining his body with HRT (he’s 22 and was never gender dysphoric til a year ago) I agree. Please remember us too. Each day is a struggle. I’d love some wins in the culture but I really pray for a win in my family.

Expand full comment

Abigail's focus is on girls. Look at the title of her book. Stop derailing.

Somebody else is going to have write a book on boys. I feel bad for your son, but he's an adult male, not a 13 year old girl, which is the focus of Abigail's work.

Expand full comment
Jan 1·edited Jan 2

Kat, this article is about a much broader point than just the ROGD issue or that of ROGD girls. Shrier talked about the southern border, crime, DEI affecting our society negatively. It was broad look at political differences and disagreements in the public sphere that can possibly lead to bitterness or "I told you so" attitudes. I simply wanted the ROGD issue, which is obviously a passion of her's , to include the significant percentage of boys and young men who fit that category. That is all I am asking. Those of us with sons, whether teens or immature young adults, are also at risk to feel intense emotions about our kids that could lead to bitterness. Not a unreasonable stance for me to take. I notice you mention the role of porn and other negative influences on why the boys adopt trans identities. But my son, and a large percentage of the boys, are autistic. My son is most likely asexual, and knowing his incredibly sweet and naïve personality would find porn very upsetting and gross. If you listen at all to AZ Hakeem( psychiatrist in UK) talk about his male patients (over 20 years treating this population) often the ASD guys are gullible, afraid of sex, and extremely vulnerable. So while I care deeply about ALL the young people caught up in this, girls and boys, I simply am looking for inclusion and consideration for the boys in this discussion. I care about the girls, and our boys are clearly NOT their enemy. They are victims too. So please consider that fact.

Expand full comment

You're missing an important point. These girls are the collateral damage of a male-driven obsession, enabled by male over-entitlement. Which is signified among other things by people going on and on and on about the poor boys while having nothing to say about the fact that the vast majority of victims are girls.

Girls are literally fleeing girlhood for boyhood, because they think girlhood is worthless, because of this.

The males on the other hand, are largely suffering from the OPPOSITE. Thinking that they are the center of all and their own feelz are the most important thing in the universe. Again, because the adults teach them that through their words and actions.

The men who feel entitled to invade women's spaces were once boys who were taught that girls' boundaries weren't worth being respected.

The result is a gender ideology movement made up of a whole lot of women with low self-esteem/ego being directed by a relative few mentally-ill men with excessively high self-esteem/ego.

I really hope you get that, so that you are able to maybe not take it personally when someone like Kat sensibly says, shut up already about the boys.

I'm sure you and the other moms of sons don't want to hear it, and I understand. But the fact remains. We need to focus more on the girls, less on the boys.

Expand full comment

Both boys and girls are suffering from the impact of gender ideology. Any practical action, such as getting the California initiative on the ballot, will help both.

Expand full comment

The Jewish Pioneers of Sexual Degeneracy in 1920s Berlin . . . by Michael Walsh . . .

IN 1919, Magnus Hirschfeld and Arthur Kronfeld, founded the “Institut für Sexualwissenschaft” (Institute for ‘Sexual Research’) in Berlin. Both were active in the German Communist Party and were prominent members of Berlin’s Jewish community.

A multitude of degenerate services were offered at the institute, including the first surgical sex changes in modern history, abortions, lectures and ‘sex counseling’, room rentals, a large library of pornography and erotic literature on every possible perversion (including bestiality and pedophilia), and a Museum of Sex featuring a wide array of homosexual fetish items, dildos, “masturbation machines”, etc.

The institute hosted tens of thousands of visitors each year, including school class field trips. Hirschfeld was a notorious sodomite, popularly known in the Berlin gay scene by his cross-dresser name Tante Magnesia.

He also founded a committee for gay rights and wrote and published many degenerate books and journals, including Jahrbuch für Sexuelle Zwischenstufen (Yearbook for Intermediate Sexual Types). In fact, he’s the sinister figure that coined the term ‘transvestite’. Hirschfeld campaigned to end the Berlin police department’s arrest of cross-dressers and prostitutes . . .

https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/06/the-jewish-pioneers-of-sexual-degeneracy-in-1920s-berlin/

Expand full comment

Yes. No argument here. The root causes are another matter.

Expand full comment
Jan 2·edited Jan 2

No YOU shut up. My son is not an over-entitled anything. Frankly that's exactly what you sound like. If he thought he was the center of the universe by being a boy he would stay one! What you said makes no sense. Even if this problem is male driven my son and the other young men are equally victims. Over 30% of ROGD cohort are male. That is not insignificant. That should not be ignored. I feel like women like you are so obsessed with your men hatred you are unable to learn. Or open your minds or be compassionate. How sad. I'm done trying to educate you.

Expand full comment

Your son is just one (1) dot of many that researchers seek connection between.

It's pretty clear from the clinical research that the motivations of the affected males are overall somewhat different than the motivations of the affected females. Autogynephilia, the fetish that affects at least half of trans-identified males, is a narcissistic disorder. The opposite condition, autoandrophilia, is nearly non-existent in the trans-identified females. They are largely motivated by self-loathing.

Significant fractions of both are motivated by internalized homophobia, so they do have that in common. Obviously, it's a complex phenomenon, having multiple unrelated causes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blanchard%27s_transsexualism_typology

Expand full comment

The plight of young men is under-examined. How are men supposed to relate to women? Whatever happens, the men get blamed.

There is one thing we know - marriages are down, stable relationships are down. This culture of "complete acquiesance" in matters of sex is not working. Men don't know what to do, how to make that first step. Women want to be in relationships, but won't agree to open to romance and relationships.

Thank goodness I am not on the dating market. It's not working for men or women.

Expand full comment

"How are men supposed to relate to women?"

They can begin by stop watching porn, specifically the violent porn today that are designed to degrade girls and women and normalize choking, slapping, spitting, and sorry to be crude, anal. Sure there are always a fringe segment of adults who are into that, and I pass no judgment on them. But pre-teens are literally getting their sex ed from this kind of porn now. So how can boys grow up into men who can relate to women this way?

Talk to Millennials and GenZ women and they absolutely will not believe you when you tell them men in older generations don't all watch porn. Porn is so normal with them they can't conceive of a time when a majority of men didn't watch or read porn (or grow out of it after their teenage years). And those were daddy's porn which, comparing to now, are just quaint.

But nobody wants to talk about that. Men don't want to give up porn, and parents still have no idea what their kids are watching nor do they seem to care to find out. Tell the average GenZ or boomer parents and they'll deny things are that bad, or they are absolutely certain their kids aren't watching those.

Expand full comment

That's a pretty sensible comment. Porn creates a completely unrealistic and toxic view of women. The sensibilities of porn are not good, and the consumption of porn does seem to lead to an escalation of titillation, which does lead to the violent side.

I also am amazed at the penetration of porn into younger and younger kids. This is yet another reason why device use in young persons should be monitored. No one should have a device in a private space before they are adults. That's not realistic of course in today's world.

I don't agree that porn is necessarily toxic, however.

Expand full comment

It's not escalation of titillation leading to violent side. Porn today literally is violent. It's not our daddy's porn. Nothing titillating. It's outright group of men using force, choking, slapping, and various other acts of degradation. Porn has normalized all of it. I don't know how true it is but I've heard some people say terrorists watch a lot of porn to fuel their violence. Laptops confiscated from terrorists are loaded with modern porn. While I have no evidence this allegation is true, it's not hard to make a connection of this to the Hamas mass rape.

Abigail hasn't looked into this, but porn is now also one of the pipelines into trans, putting the autogynephilia ideas into minds of young men.

I'm GenX. I know for a fact my male peers didn't and don't read or watch porn like it's normal because we didn't have the internet. Grown me who bought stroke books were generally considered to be losers. Even now, most men I know of my own generation are pretty social media averse, and not online 24/7. They're fathers and they aren't even aware how degenerate porn has become today. Every time I tell younger women that GenX men in fact do not all watch porn, they don't believe me.

Expand full comment

It's beyond obvious that the Hamas monsters watched violent porn. And I mean a hell of a lot of it.

If today's porn causes normal, middle class, American teenage boys to choke their girlfriends, imagine what it did to the terrorists of Hamas. These Islamist maniacs didn't just rape and kill beautiful, young women. They chopped off breasts and shot up the vaginas to get sexual kicks. And they captured all the sick, stomach-turning savagery on video and broadcast their vile, sadistic snuff films to the cheers of crowds throughout Gaza, Islam, and the "Progressive" West.

Expand full comment

-

Jews and Muslims have similar roots and customs . . .

-

“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13

-

“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464

-

Expand full comment

It's not underexamined. Every conversation about girls and women is derailed to males. All medical research has disproportionately focused on males, for decades.

Nobody cares about your dating life, George. Stop derailing conversations about women. Go somewhere else if you want to talk about males. Stop it.

Expand full comment

Well, you know nothing, obviously, about medical research. I have sat on 45 or so NIH panels, and every single one examines the inclusion of women, minorities, etc in medical research, in every single grant application.

Stop derailing conversations with your ignorant confusion.

Expand full comment

You're way off, Kat. Your comment would have been true 50 years ago and earlier, but definitely not for the past 30 years.

The U.S. government spends more than twice as much annually on breast cancer research and grants ($560 billion in 2021) than on prostate cancer. ($270 billion.)

Breast cancer kills about 48,000 people per year, compared to 43,000 for lung cancer ($470 billion in 2021) and about 40,000 for prostate cancer. Funding for breast cancer is actually disproportionately higher than it would be if funding were allocated actuarially based on incidence and death tolls.

You can bring bitterness and a bad attitude to substack boards popular with independently minded subscribers, but if you provide zero data to back up whatever you're bitter about, you won't win any converts.

Do you have any recent data to support your assertion? (Preferably something more recent than 100 years or 6,000 years ago?)

After googling around for 20 minutes, I'm not finding info that supports your contention. Seems more like the reverse, at least during this century.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

Breast cancer gets male attention because men like talking and thinking about boobs a lot more than they like talking and thinking about their prostates.

Meanwhile, girls think womanhood sucks so bad that they'd rather cut off their breasts and be boys. We need to focus on making girlhood and womanhood a less miserable experience.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

I think it worth saying here that the cancer industry is generally a scam. Women tend to be more vulnerable to fear of cancer and big pharma exploit this.

It has weaseled its way into government and its agencies and now poisons people including a very great many women with its toxic treatments which do nobody any good except provide profit for big pharma and its investors.

https://alphaandomegacloud.wordpress.com/2022/02/04/world-cancer-day/

I have myself seen the cancer industry from the inside as it where in 2020 when I was given immuno-therapy for an alleged cancer which I now know to have been in essence fraudulent.

By the way, your comment went to George Q Tyrebyter rather than Kat Highsmith.

Expand full comment

Could you please just stop with this nonsense? Males have been the focus of research for years. That's why doctors know so little about women's issues with endometriosis, menstruation, PCOS, etc., as they've been historically ignored by male medical establishments. What you say means nothing.

Entire books have been written about the lack of research involving females because males are seen as the default by other males (Invisible Women by Caroline Criado Perez). Women have always been considered defective and inferior to men. Why study us? Male doctors for centuries knew nothing about female reproductive systems. "Hysteria" was thought to be the womb trying to escape from the body (male logic ftw).

Stop derailing with your constant whining about men. Go obsess over yourselves elsewhere and leave women alone, and hopefully Abigail blocks you. You're indicative of the problem, and you're too dumb to see it, thereby proving the point. Go away.

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/nov/13/the-female-problem-male-bias-in-medical-trials

Expand full comment

Since 1993, this has been a federal mandate. I don't give a shit what the morons at the Guardian say. That's a liberal publication from the UK, and therefore is wrong about everything.

If you wish to be educated, you can look at the actual Federal statutes.

https://grants.nih.gov/policy/inclusion/women-and-minorities.htm

But from your comments, written with spite and ignorance, suggest that you are not interested in facts, just venting your sclerotic rage.

Expand full comment

To be fair George, I am from the UK and the Guardian is not wrong about everything, just highly biased and wrong about a lot of things.

But all traditional newspapers are poor nowadays and it is hard to find a truly balanced article.

Expand full comment

The Jewish Psychological Operation to Blame White Women...

“This desire to control women and view them as essentially worthless comes directly from jewish brains, going all the way back to blaming evil Eve for taking the apple in the garden of Eden. Observant jews thank YHVH every morning “that He didn’t make me a gentile, that He didn’t make me a woman, that He didn’t make me an ignoramus.” The Tractate Shabbat, sums up the attitude of jewish religious law toward women: they are “a sack full of excrement” with a bleeding hole. Jewish men essentially enslave their women and treat them worse than dogs...”

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/the-jewish-psychological-operation-to-blame-white-women

Expand full comment

Kat, you are obviously a very bitter person. Reread Abigail’s article..

Expand full comment

I'm talking about the topic in general and male self-obsession and exclusion of women in general.

Her book is about girls, and every conversation about women and girls HAS to be derailed by some stupid moid who thinks the past 6,000 years of history focusing on males isn't enough. They, and you, simply cannot leave women alone. You can see the comments here. This is why "male allies" don't exist.

Calling me bitter doesn't change this. Nice argument though; it really addresses the point I made.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment
deletedJan 1·edited Jan 1
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Wow. You don't own this space, honey. Stop pretending to be the cop.

Expand full comment

In what the late Saddam Hussein once dubbed “the great Satan,” roughly two-thirds of the United States enlisted military corps is white . . . The fat, bulbous U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin once confirmed in a 93-2 vote of the U.S. Senate, immediately embarked on a whirlwind media tour of duty, telling the pseudo-secular sycophants in the state-controlled tabloid press and state-controlled television talk show circuit about how the U.S. Army is full of bad racist white men.

Senior Defense Department leaders celebrating yet another Pride Month at the Pentagon sounding the alarm about the rising number of state laws they say target the LGBTQ+ community, warned the trend is hurting the feelings of the armed forces . . . “LGBTQ plus and other diverse communities are under attack, just because they are different. Hate for hate’s sake,” said Gil Cisneros, the Pentagon’s undersecretary for personnel and readiness, who also serves as DoD’s chief diversity and inclusion officer.

And now the U.S. Army is doing ads begging for more young white males? What happened?

Even with a full-on declaration of war from Congress, and even if Gavin Newsome could be cheated into the Oval Office by ZOG somehow, with Globohomo diversity brigades going door-to-door looking to impress American children into military service, they will be met with armed, well-trained opposition, the invasion at the Southern border is going full tilt, and the drugs are flowing in like never before.

Get ready for it . . . the fat old devil worshipping fags on Capitol Hill, on Wall Street, in Whitehall, and in Brussels are in no shape to fight a war themselves, and most Americans are armed to the teeth with their own guns . . . NATO hates heterosexual white men . . . they said so themselves . . .

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/nato-an-anti-white-and-anti-family-institution

Expand full comment
deletedJan 1
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
deletedJan 1·edited Jan 1
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Hi George: I was responding to Kat but my comment got misplaced under yours. Apologies!

Expand full comment

Not a problem. As I noted, it's easy to get these nested comments all confused up.

Happy New Year!!! May the Gender Woo Wackos be taken to the woodshed and mercilessly thrashed!!!

Expand full comment
deletedJan 1
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Gee, honey, you seem upset. You need to calm down.

Expand full comment

The Jewish Pioneers of Sexual Degeneracy in 1920s Berlin . . . by Michael Walsh . . .

IN 1919, Magnus Hirschfeld and Arthur Kronfeld, founded the “Institut für Sexualwissenschaft” (Institute for ‘Sexual Research’) in Berlin. Both were active in the German Communist Party and were prominent members of Berlin’s Jewish community.

A multitude of degenerate services were offered at the institute, including the first surgical sex changes in modern history, abortions, lectures and ‘sex counseling’, room rentals, a large library of pornography and erotic literature on every possible perversion (including bestiality and pedophilia), and a Museum of Sex featuring a wide array of homosexual fetish items, dildos, “masturbation machines”, etc.

The institute hosted tens of thousands of visitors each year, including school class field trips. Hirschfeld was a notorious sodomite, popularly known in the Berlin gay scene by his cross-dresser name Tante Magnesia.

He also founded a committee for gay rights and wrote and published many degenerate books and journals, including Jahrbuch für Sexuelle Zwischenstufen (Yearbook for Intermediate Sexual Types). In fact, he’s the sinister figure that coined the term ‘transvestite’. Hirschfeld campaigned to end the Berlin police department’s arrest of cross-dressers and prostitutes . . .

https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/06/the-jewish-pioneers-of-sexual-degeneracy-in-1920s-berlin/

Expand full comment

You are the problem.

Thanks for proving it.

Expand full comment

No, you’re the problem Kat. He has every right to express an opinion and who are you to tell him to “go away.” You sound like a bully.

Expand full comment

I unsubscribed to the New York Times after my historically happy and non-dysphoric daughter decided she was a guy, aided and abetted by our local Marxist Indoctrination Factory—aka her high school. They all can kiss my bitter butt. So I guess I missed the big reveal that the left changed its mind on "gender affirmative care." can someone fill me in? Thank you!

Expand full comment

The left liberal wackawoo side HAS NOT CHANGED its views on gender affirming care. But there is a strong push against this and the wind of gender insanity has diminished. The fight is not over, and the left is pushing. But the cultural push is not as strong.

Expand full comment

My older teen girl, 16, was also historically happy as another commenter stated above about her daughter, and became entranced by gender ideology at age 14, which then “infected” her little sister who’d had to be hospitalized during the pandemic with anorexia in 2021 and who is now 13.

The older girl seems to be coming out of it a bit, the younger girl has not come out of it yet and has a cohort of other girls who are also swept up in it.

And though I am sensing a change in the “wind”, it has been a scarring hellscape and there are still liberal creeps on our small middle school PTA who push back when I’ve brought up that maybe the sex education curriculum with ‘human rights dot org/welcoming schools dot org (advocates for transgenderism)’ stamped at the bottom of the school sex education slides for 7th graders describing group sex and anal sex and that there can be “dozens of genders!” is maybe not age-appropriate.

I even contacted the salaried school administration person in charge of health curriculum and she said the ‘welcoming schools dot org’ group was an “approved” resource by the school board and she went on to say this is all a part of DEI. This public school board in Montgomery County, Maryland, US, also has the policy of making teachers and school administrators keep SECRETS from parents about not telling parents if a child goes by a different name or pronouns at the school, thus triangulating parents away from their child who would, by definition, be suffering from a mental health issue (confused, struggling). We still need more people to say this is not okay and is HARMING our kids, and to Abigail Schrier’s point, our country.

My girls are lovely, sensitive and intelligent girls who are white and didn’t want to be the “oppressor” and didn’t want to not be ‘cool’.

I fell for a lot of this stuff myself and how come no one has brought up how awful a candidate trump is/was? Besides, my younger (white) brothers who supported him seemed a bit “tecched in the head” with their pro-guns and prepper, anti-vax (ALL vaccines), and Ancient Aliens propaganda. Sometimes it can be hard to know who to believe...

But I have TWO copies of Abigail Schrier’s first book and have pre-ordered her upcoming book after a VERY BAD experience with both my older daughter’s American Academy of Pediatrics-following pediatrician and that doctor’s office’s in-house psychologist, and my younger daughter’s (only belatedly realized), “gender affirming”-ONLY psychologist for VERY BAD ADVICE/BAD THERAPY.

So, there are winds hopefully changing, and I am so very sorry that I was late to the party given, selfishly, that it has caused my family such utter distress that we are not even fully through yet. But more exposure is needed and more personal stories that show the utter pain and fracture of such pure loving, hearts that may show school boards, pediatricians, therapists, members of congress and other lawmakers some damn LOGIC.

This is my corner of the world in the logic argument described in Ms. Schrier’s post here, because this is where my family and extended family have been personally impacted, but I do see how, like a paradigm for other opportunities for logic, this also applies to masking, covid vaccines, our southern border, DEI bullcrap, and anti-semitism. I feel “woke” in a completely different way now, y’all.

Expand full comment

Sorry to hear about your daughters being harmed by this ideology. If you are able I would get out of Montgomery County, MD. Find another place to live where the schools are so entrenched in this Woke-nonsense. Also, there are lots of people who are centrist and conservative that aren’t like your brothers-- but I do think a lot of white young men are drawn to Trump because under DEI, the white man is bad and evil, but Trump doesn’t buy into that and doesn’t tell young white men that crap. Perhaps more of us need to listen to these men to understand before we judge them too harshly for being trump supporters. Or perhaps we need to make more space for them at the table of other conservative candidates. Just a thought. But thanks for sharing your story and welcome.

Expand full comment

Better yet, find other parents who do not want their children mutilated, and get activists opposed to gender woo on the School boards.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

Any teacher who talks to 7th graders (that's what , 12 y.o.??!!) about group sex and anal sex should lose their teaching license, at the very least. I am beginning to think that sex education should be left entirely up to the family. Are you a liberal "sex-positive" parent? Go ahead and buy your kid a huge box of condoms for Christmas. Are you a religious conservative parent? Feel free to talk to your kid about romantic courtship and the benefits of waiting. Schools need to stay out of it.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

I agree about Trump. He's a toxic swamp of toxic shit.

Note that, even now, he is NOT supported by a majority of GOP voters, but rather by a PLURALITY. He is a skilled campaigner, who has managed to keep the opposition divided. The window to defeat him is not closed, but the time is coming when it will be too late. I hope that sense returns to GOP voters. I despise him, myself, even though he is right on a lot of issues.

Expand full comment

Ilhan Omar (D-MN) and Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) have every right to say what they like about Israel and the genocide of Palestinians as elected members of the US House of Representatives; they never took an oath to serve Israel . . .

I voted for Ron Desantis (R-FL) to be governor of Florida, not ambassador to Israel.

The recently ousted Speaker of the US House of Representatives, Congressman Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), who took at least a dozen votes to get elected speaker, traveled to Israel immediately upon his election, declaring to the Israeli Knesset that the USA is steadfastly committed to supporting Ukraine in their war against Russia . . .

Was he running for speaker of the Israeli Knesset too?

Following his ouster . . . McCarthy (R-CA) traveled abroad again, this time to England, and expressed his open contempt for the white Republicans who make up the majority of the GOP and praised Democrats for their diversity during a debate at Oxford in the wake of his ouster as House Speaker . . .

Is he now running for the Prime Minister of the U.K.?

Nevertheless, he is free to go on media tours bashing white people and lobbying for Israel, because he has now resigned from the US House of Representatives . . . I can only conclude that the collective RINO butthurt over former Speaker McCarthy is all about the Israelis who have hijacked the American deep state war machine.

It has become so painfully obvious, especially where you have someone like Nikki Haley wagging her finger and shouting down Vivek Ramaswamy in a presidential debate on live national television when the questions of this Ukrainian war against Russia and any mention of Israel are concerned, that the United States government has become a wholly owned subsidiary of the American Israeli Political Action Committee.

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/fight-your-own-wars-you-kikesucking-zionist-ass-whores

Expand full comment

Trump is a thoroughly corrupt criminal sociopath. I utterly despise him.

But I'm going to vote for him anyway, because I WILL NOT do ANYTHING to empower gender ideology, which is fully backed by 99.9% of Democrats holding elected office (and 100% of those in the US Congress).

Expand full comment

Let's hope that is not the choice. But I completely understand your view here.

Expand full comment

In what the late Saddam Hussein once dubbed “the great Satan,” roughly two-thirds of the United States enlisted military corps is white . . . The fat, bulbous U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin once confirmed in a 93-2 vote of the U.S. Senate, immediately embarked on a whirlwind media tour of duty, telling the pseudo-secular sycophants in the state-controlled tabloid press and state-controlled television talk show circuit about how the U.S. Army is full of bad racist white men.

Senior Defense Department leaders celebrating yet another Pride Month at the Pentagon sounding the alarm about the rising number of state laws they say target the LGBTQ+ community, warned the trend is hurting the feelings of the armed forces . . . “LGBTQ plus and other diverse communities are under attack, just because they are different. Hate for hate’s sake,” said Gil Cisneros, the Pentagon’s undersecretary for personnel and readiness, who also serves as DoD’s chief diversity and inclusion officer.

And now the U.S. Army is doing ads begging for more young white males? What happened?

Even with a full-on declaration of war from Congress, and even if Gavin Newsome could be cheated into the Oval Office by ZOG somehow, with Globohomo diversity brigades going door-to-door looking to impress American children into military service, they will be met with armed, well-trained opposition, the invasion at the Southern border is going full tilt, and the drugs are flowing in like never before.

Get ready for it . . . the fat old devil worshipping fags on Capitol Hill, on Wall Street, in Whitehall, and in Brussels are in no shape to fight a war themselves, and most Americans are armed to the teeth with their own guns . . . NATO hates heterosexual white men . . . they said so themselves . . .

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/nato-an-anti-white-and-anti-family-institution

Expand full comment

I am very sorry to hear of your daughters 'infection' with the gender ideology nonsense. It is a very great evil.

As regards the school boards, pediatricians, therapists, members of congress and other lawmakers their so called logic is governed by money, the love of it, along with the power to manipulate people.

As regards vaccines, all vaccines are and were completely pointless at best. I used to think they were of some use but not for the 'flu as people fell ill anyway.

In 2020 after researching properly I realised they are a gross deceit and gigantic fraud. They have done immense damage to children let alone adults.

https://baldmichael.substack.com/p/why-vaccines-do-not-work-in-a-nutshell

https://alphaandomegacloud.wordpress.com/2022/11/14/vaccination-industry-in-a-nutshell/

Expand full comment

Wow thank you--as an American Jewish Zionist and a Lesbian against both hamas AND gender equality ideology-this was the bright , poignant, and hopeful essay I needed to read. Because all identity aside-I want to live in a fair and free American/West by those who want the same. This is the good fight!

Expand full comment

You said, “...all identity aside...” while leading with your identities to show your “intersectional cred”. I’m not trying to be harsh, but you seem to have rather missed the point of Ms Shrier’s piece (that all this “identitarianism” is literally destroying us, our society, and our children/future).

My wish for 2024 is that we ALL stop “leading with our identity”, and start leading with our humanity. So much more constructive, so much more likely to result in a culture we would all like to live in.

Expand full comment

numbnuts i led with that to show that someone with an identity like mine that might be stereotyped into blind progressivism sees the truth. if you’re so triggered by it you’re no better than a snowflake liberal

Expand full comment

The Jewish Pioneers of Sexual Degeneracy in 1920s Berlin . . . by Michael Walsh . . .

IN 1919, Magnus Hirschfeld and Arthur Kronfeld, founded the “Institut für Sexualwissenschaft” (Institute for ‘Sexual Research’) in Berlin. Both were active in the German Communist Party and were prominent members of Berlin’s Jewish community.

A multitude of degenerate services were offered at the institute, including the first surgical sex changes in modern history, abortions, lectures and ‘sex counseling’, room rentals, a large library of pornography and erotic literature on every possible perversion (including bestiality and pedophilia), and a Museum of Sex featuring a wide array of homosexual fetish items, dildos, “masturbation machines”, etc.

The institute hosted tens of thousands of visitors each year, including school class field trips. Hirschfeld was a notorious sodomite, popularly known in the Berlin gay scene by his cross-dresser name Tante Magnesia.

He also founded a committee for gay rights and wrote and published many degenerate books and journals, including Jahrbuch für Sexuelle Zwischenstufen (Yearbook for Intermediate Sexual Types). In fact, he’s the sinister figure that coined the term ‘transvestite’. Hirschfeld campaigned to end the Berlin police department’s arrest of cross-dressers and prostitutes . . .

https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/06/the-jewish-pioneers-of-sexual-degeneracy-in-1920s-berlin/

Expand full comment

Zionists should be forced to live in Zion.

Expand full comment

And where will you be forced to live?

Expand full comment

Force me to live on the land I love. Force me to die on my country. Force me to live on my native California.

Expand full comment

But it's not yours. It belongs to Mexico. It belongs to Native Americans. Remember?

Expand full comment

California belongs to the people who live and die here. We know the stories. Mexica never ruled California. Nobody rules California. California was a republic for twenty thousand years. It is now a constitutional republic. I never learned the lies of the liars. Millions of us laugh at your lies. Your books are mostly lies.

Expand full comment
Jan 1Liked by Abigail Shrier

love, love, love your perspective and challenge to love those who didn't and don't love us

Expand full comment

How come Bill Ackman only noticed this after Israel started getting criticized?

Expand full comment

Go on. Say it. Don’t mince words.

Expand full comment

Kat, please post your vile comments somewhere else.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

For Kat, ‘Israel being criticized’ = supporting Hamas rampage and denying atrocities. And bill Ackman meets regularly with the Elders of Zion.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

Can you answer the question?

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

Because he was directed by the Elders of Zion. Obviously.

Expand full comment

Ilhan Omar (D-MN) and Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) have every right to say what they like about Israel and the genocide of Palestinians as elected members of the US House of Representatives; they never took an oath to serve Israel . . .

I voted for Ron Desantis (R-FL) to be governor of Florida, not ambassador to Israel.

The recently ousted Speaker of the US House of Representatives, Congressman Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), who took at least a dozen votes to get elected speaker, traveled to Israel immediately upon his election, declaring to the Israeli Knesset that the USA is steadfastly committed to supporting Ukraine in their war against Russia . . .

Was he running for speaker of the Israeli Knesset too?

Following his ouster . . . McCarthy (R-CA) traveled abroad again, this time to England, and expressed his open contempt for the white Republicans who make up the majority of the GOP and praised Democrats for their diversity during a debate at Oxford in the wake of his ouster as House Speaker . . .

Is he now running for the Prime Minister of the U.K.?

Nevertheless, he is free to go on media tours bashing white people and lobbying for Israel, because he has now resigned from the US House of Representatives . . . I can only conclude that the collective RINO butthurt over former Speaker McCarthy is all about the Israelis who have hijacked the American deep state war machine.

It has become so painfully obvious, especially where you have someone like Nikki Haley wagging her finger and shouting down Vivek Ramaswamy in a presidential debate on live national television when the questions of this Ukrainian war against Russia and any mention of Israel are concerned, that the United States government has become a wholly owned subsidiary of the American Israeli Political Action Committee.

https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/satanism-is-a-jewish-cult

Expand full comment
Jan 1Liked by Abigail Shrier

Thank you Abigail, you are always such a breath of fresh air. Wish I heard more from you. God Bless and Happy New Year. 🤍

Expand full comment

This article hits home, as I was deeply disappointed by an article that Shrier wrote on Substack a while back which, IMO, was critical of folks like me who came out strongly against Covid tyranny. I expressed my disappointment in the comments, thinking that someone who was perceptive enough to realize how much damage was being caused by the gender madness should recognize folks like me as brothers in arms.

In any event, it sounds like Shrier has come around on this issue and, as she is recommending, I will not hold any bitterness toward her.

Expand full comment

I agree with the sentiment, but at the same time there's something to be said for being a little bit tough and rough with people. Because I think that this left wing radicalism that you describe so well advances because it intimidates people into silence. It isn't nice. It scares the supposedly neutral institutions into going along with them. Conservatives don't scare them as much, which might be why things are the way that they are. A harsh reality perhaps but I think it's true.

Expand full comment

The Left is extremely tyrannical, so many people fired, cancelled, etc. I was once banned by Facebook for 90 days for reposting a funny Hunter Biden meme. First offense. I never post anything political.

People are cowed into silence and actually silenced. I agree that we do have to fight back, in a meaningful and productive way.

Expand full comment

Agreed. I will pull no punches with people. They say offense is the best form of defence, so one must not sit on it, the fence that is!

Expand full comment

Thanks for the encouragement Abigail! I would take issue with “our positions became conventional wisdom,”. I don’t see very many around me who have “seen the light “. Many “regular” people seem still to have not gotten the word. I decided after a family visit that I just have to pick my battles because the mass delusion is still operating. On the other hand, there is a growing opposition from all kinds of unexpected places and THAT is encouraging. I fear, however, that we as a nation are heading for a split. The “vaccinated” vs the “unvaccinated “ metaphorically speaking.

Expand full comment

The kind of person who believes keeping an 8 year old out of a soccer league because her mother is guilty of wrongthink is truly dangerous. Someone who would hurt a child for the sole purpose of "punishing" her mother wouldn't hesitate to: try and get said parent fired from her job; make her lose her professional licenses; restrict her freedom; use state power to fine her or imprison her.

This behavior speaks volumes about her view of liberalism, civil rights, and our common humanity. Someone who will deny a child's rights to play soccer because of her parents politics will happily deny other rights to said parents, patting herself on the back (ala Delores Umbrage) for her compassion the whole time.

Expand full comment

Delores Umbrage, great analogy!

Expand full comment

Lol, Matt Walsh is one to talk about not being there on the gender thing until just 5 minutes ago. Feminists like Janice Raymond (70s), Meghan Murphy and Julie Bindel have been "shouting from the rooftops" for decades, long before Walsh got on board by using the exact same feminists' arguments while screaming "where are all the feminists???".

And even though I think he's an arrogant misogynist dick who openly hates feminists, I welcome Walsh to the party, appreciate his work "What is a Woman?", and hope he takes your advice, Abigail. Thanks for this very thoughtful piece.

Expand full comment

As a conservative myself, I continually have been asking liberals "If every liberal policy is a failure, and all the conservative notions are successful, tell me again WHY you stick to the liberal side?" Immigration. Gender woo wack. Cancel culture. Anti-jew screaming. Drug policy. Homelessness. BLM and race hustling anti-white garbage. Rampant inflation caused by "Fight for $15". Exploding crime in cities due to failure to prosecute criminals. Letting criminals out without bail to commit more crimes. Prices rising due to minimum wage increases.

What have liberals done LATELY that works? I can't think of a single thing.

Expand full comment

Everything you listed IS their policy and the outcomes ARE their goal. So from their sick point of view it’s a screaming success and anyone who disagrees is a racist, transphobic Marxist.

Expand full comment

Fascist rather than Marxist I think.

Expand full comment

Heinrich Himmler on How Bolshevik Christianity Spreads Homosexuality and Hatred of Women . . .

❝150 years ago someone at a Catholic university wrote a doctoral thesis with the title: “Does a woman have a soul?” From this the whole tendency of Christianity emerges: it is directed at the absolute destruction of women and at emphasizing the inferiority of women. The entire substance of the priesthood and of the whole of Christianity is, I am firmly convinced, an erotic union of men (Männerbund) for the erection and maintenance of this 2,000-year old Bolshevism . . .

The German woman, not the man, has borne the greater sacrifice of blood in the witch and heretic trials. The priests knew exactly why they burned 5,000-6,000 women: exactly because they emotionally held fast to the old knowledge and the old doctrine and emotionally and instinctively could not be dissuaded from them, while the man had already converted by logic and thought…❞

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/heinrich-himmler-on-how-bolshevik-christianity-spreads-homosexuality-and-hatred-of-women

Expand full comment

It's what we liberals haven't done. We haven't robbed women of control over their reproduction. We haven't made it possible for deranged males to slaughter men, women and children in our cities with weapons of war. We aren't putting the pedal to the metal on climate change. We didn't open the door for white Christian Nationalists to begin turning the US into a theocracy. We didn't pretend Donald J. Trump was unimpeachable.

Expand full comment

No, you liberals just continue to fund the USA's wars of aggression so that the arms manufacturers' still profit (they support all sides of course), you ignore the real issues of pollution (climate change is a red herring), you support by default the radical Islamists who will turn the USA into a caliphate with sharia law, and you voted an imbecile called Joe Biden into power when even Bernie Sanders was obviously more competent.

And you supported lockdowns and masks and mandatory vaccination by and large as bossing people around is enjoyed by the hypocritical left as much as the right.

Expand full comment

In what the late Saddam Hussein once dubbed “the great Satan,” roughly two-thirds of the United States enlisted military corps is white . . . The fat, bulbous U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin once confirmed in a 93-2 vote of the U.S. Senate, immediately embarked on a whirlwind media tour of duty, telling the pseudo-secular sycophants in the state-controlled tabloid press and state-controlled television talk show circuit about how the U.S. Army is full of bad racist white men.

Senior Defense Department leaders celebrating yet another Pride Month at the Pentagon sounding the alarm about the rising number of state laws they say target the LGBTQ+ community, warned the trend is hurting the feelings of the armed forces . . . “LGBTQ plus and other diverse communities are under attack, just because they are different. Hate for hate’s sake,” said Gil Cisneros, the Pentagon’s undersecretary for personnel and readiness, who also serves as DoD’s chief diversity and inclusion officer.

And now the U.S. Army is doing ads begging for more young white males? What happened?

Even with a full-on declaration of war from Congress, and even if Gavin Newsome could be cheated into the Oval Office by ZOG somehow, with Globohomo diversity brigades going door-to-door looking to impress American children into military service, they will be met with armed, well-trained opposition, the invasion at the Southern border is going full tilt, and the drugs are flowing in like never before.

Get ready for it . . . the fat old devil worshipping fags on Capitol Hill, on Wall Street, in Whitehall, and in Brussels are in no shape to fight a war themselves, and most Americans are armed to the teeth with their own guns . . . NATO hates heterosexual white men . . . they said so themselves . . .

https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/nato-an-anti-white-and-anti-family-institution

Expand full comment

They don't see any of what you brought up as failures. They see them as the policies are working.

Seriously, talk to some East and West Coast liberals and you'll find people who agree with these policies and outcomes.

Expand full comment

Everything you mention in your article has been a battle for me one way or another. The DEI insanity did end up making me bitter. Ultimately, I have given up fighting it, but now playing the waiting game to see how it all pans out. It is hard to imagine the craziness that we have had to endure since 2020 and now for those on the left to slowly be waking up from the madness of it all is in itself astonishing to behold. How they didn’t see the writing on the wall in the first place is the bottom line concern. I think a movie needs to be made to showcase just how much has changed in our country since 2020.

Expand full comment

The Jewish Pioneers of Sexual Degeneracy in 1920s Berlin . . . by Michael Walsh . . .

IN 1919, Magnus Hirschfeld and Arthur Kronfeld, founded the “Institut für Sexualwissenschaft” (Institute for ‘Sexual Research’) in Berlin. Both were active in the German Communist Party and were prominent members of Berlin’s Jewish community.

A multitude of degenerate services were offered at the institute, including the first surgical sex changes in modern history, abortions, lectures and ‘sex counseling’, room rentals, a large library of pornography and erotic literature on every possible perversion (including bestiality and pedophilia), and a Museum of Sex featuring a wide array of homosexual fetish items, dildos, “masturbation machines”, etc.

The institute hosted tens of thousands of visitors each year, including school class field trips. Hirschfeld was a notorious sodomite, popularly known in the Berlin gay scene by his cross-dresser name Tante Magnesia.

He also founded a committee for gay rights and wrote and published many degenerate books and journals, including Jahrbuch für Sexuelle Zwischenstufen (Yearbook for Intermediate Sexual Types). In fact, he’s the sinister figure that coined the term ‘transvestite’. Hirschfeld campaigned to end the Berlin police department’s arrest of cross-dressers and prostitutes . . .

https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/06/the-jewish-pioneers-of-sexual-degeneracy-in-1920s-berlin/

Expand full comment

A call to our better selves - and pragmatic too. I may have to print this out and keep it nearby when I read the words of a newly rational person patting him or herself on the back for recognizing how bad the ideas promoted by the people he or she voted for and supported are. Especially, when they would vote the same way again because fear of conservatives, or Christians, or those who are pro-life, or Donald Trump still controls them in the voting booth.

Your words are important and a gentle way to move into 2024.

Expand full comment